Speaking as a newbie, which attracted me to the Collectors Club, A new engine raises the excitment levels a lot more to me and maybe others who are beginning to either build a collection or renew long gone collection than a piece of rolling stock. I can fully understand the views of those more experienced collectors who have extensive stocks of engines to choose from and maybe, want to remain in Era and the like, but as a way to attract new entrants to the hobby and especially the youngsters, who will be the future, I really appreciate, having paid the joining fee and receiving an engine in effect for free, rather than a peice of rolling stock, the intricacies of which will be lost on a beginner and to be fair, because of that lack of knowledge and experience, would be the same as receiving a piece of rolling stock which could be picked up elsewhere for under a Fiver. Nope Engines every time for me!