Maybe I should have written "in general "instead of "always" because out of sheer luck a consist could be right. I understand that model companies try to utulise stock they alraedy make, but that should not be a reason to falsify history. By the way: I am a bit of a CIWL expert and can judge right or wrong CIWL consists. I would not know whether other, non CIWL, sets that are made are correct or not. Regards Fred